Six months after Indonesia’s child-safety regulation took effect on 28 March 2026, the communications ministry, Komdigi, reported that about 28 million children’s accounts had been given extra protection. Roblox moved 23 million child accounts into stricter settings; TikTok said it had switched off around nine million [1]. Yet in its 14 September review the ministry judged X, Meta, YouTube and TikTok not yet fully compliant [1]. The reason matters for anyone thinking of building a business here: the regulation, known as PP Tunas, does not count closed accounts. It judges the design of each product, service and feature a child might use, and a platform proves its case in a written risk assessment that the ministry checks.
That filing is the bottleneck. By 6 September, 252 products, services and features from 94 companies had been assessed and filed, and Komdigi had finished checking 60 of them [2][12]. At the end of June the ministry warned that about 17,000 registered platforms had not filed at all [3]. The deadline is now 31 December 2026 [2][12]. Checking a user’s age has become cheap. Doing the assessment itself, feature by feature, and getting it accepted is what remains scarce.
What a platform has to hand the ministry
Companies running websites and apps for Indonesian users register with Komdigi as “electronic system operators” [3]. Under PP Tunas, an operator whose products, services or features children may use must score each of them against seven kinds of risk: contact with strangers; exposure to pornographic, violent or life-threatening content; exploitation of children as consumers; threats to their personal data; addiction; psychological harm; and physical harm [1][4]. Ministerial decrees 142/2026 and 219/2026 break those seven aspects into 58 weighted indicators and set out the templates and the procedure the ministry uses to verify each filing [1][12].
The scoring is lopsided. One aspect rated high makes the whole product high-risk; a low rating needs all seven to come back low [1][4]. On a high-risk product, children under 16 may not hold accounts and 16- and 17-year-olds need a parent’s consent [1]. Chat, user-generated content, public profiles, friend lists and live streaming all push a product toward high risk, and the burden of proof sits with the platform [5]. The ministry does not just stamp the form: lawyers who advise platforms describe back-and-forth with Komdigi before obligations are fixed, and say Komdigi has rated near-identical services differently depending on which controls each had in place when it filed [5]. An operator that does not file can have its risk profile set by the ministry itself [2][3][12].
How a PP Tunas risk rating is set
- 1. Check scope
Is the product likely to be used or accessed by children? - 2. Score seven aspects
58 weighted indicators from Decrees 142/2026 and 219/2026, with evidence - 3. File the self-assessment
Deadline 31 December 2026; non-filers can be rated by the ministry - 4. Komdigi verifies
Clarification back and forth; 60 of 252 filings verified by 6 September - 5. Rating set
High risk: no accounts under 16, parental consent at 16–17 - 6. Reassess
When features change
The consequences are already visible. Komdigi’s list of 22 high-risk products includes domestic services such as Vidio and Blibli alongside YouTube, Discord and Telegram [2]; Vidio and Blibli have to adjust their services [1]. What is not yet in force is money. Komdigi has drafted fines of up to 6% of global revenue for large platforms and up to Rp1 billion, Rp5 billion and Rp10 billion for domestic micro, small and medium operators, but they need a separate government regulation on state revenue before they can be collected [1][12].
Age checks are cheap; the assessment is not
Most of what is for sale addresses the part of PP Tunas that is easiest to buy: confirming a user’s age. Didit, an identity-verification company with Indonesian-language pages, sells facial age estimation at US$0.10 a check, with an ID-document fallback at US$0.15 for borderline cases [8]. Singapore-based k-ID sells age assurance and parental-consent tools whose pricing begins free and scales with active players per game [6]; its guide shows developers how to set Indonesia’s age limits “based on what you considered in your self-assessment” [4], and its neimo AI assistant answers compliance questions against Indonesian and other countries’ rules and drafts material for counsel to review [7]. Shufti Pro publishes a PP Tunas age-compliance checklist [10]. Law firms such as Assegaf Hamzah & Partners interpret the rules and brief clients, including in a webinar co-hosted with k-ID [5].
The assessment itself stays with the platform. Komdigi’s guidance, as relayed by counsel, advises bringing child psychologists and IT-security staff into the work alongside legal, product and sales; one partner said “you need a village to complete a self-assessment” [5]. Global giants with large compliance teams still failed the September review [1]. A mid-size Indonesian marketplace, streaming service or wallet has the same obligation per product and far fewer people. Its options today are to assign an in-house lead and use free drafts and the ministry’s templates, to buy legal advice and then implement it alone, or to do the minimum: accept a high-risk rating and shut out under-16s, which is what a high rating means for Vidio and Blibli [1][2]. The e-commerce association idEA has warned that unclear technical standards raise compliance costs for small and mid-size firms [9].
| Alternative | What the platform gets | What it still has to do itself |
|---|---|---|
| Didit, k-ID (age checks, consent) [4][6][8] | Age estimation from US$0.10 a check; age gates configured to the risk level | Score every feature, compile evidence, file and answer the ministry |
| k-ID neimo (AI drafts) [7] | Rule lookups and drafts for counsel | Turn drafts into an evidenced filing; see it through verification |
| Law firm advice [5] | Interpretation and a filing strategy | Map features, change them, assemble evidence |
| In-house lead with ministry templates [12] | Full control, no outside fee | Everything, with a team the guidance says should span law, product, security and child psychology |
| Do the minimum [1][2] | No spend now | Lose under-16 users on any high-risk product |
A firm that sells the accepted rating
The business this investigation features is a Komdigi-ready PP Tunas compliance service: a Jakarta firm that takes a mid-size domestic platform from its list of features to a rating the ministry accepts, and keeps it there. Its analysts would inventory each product’s features, score them against the 58 indicators using the ministry’s own templates, recommend changes where one aspect would tip the product into high risk, compile the evidence, file, and handle Komdigi’s questions until the rating is set. When the client adds a feature, they reassess. Age checks and parental consent would be bought from existing vendors such as Didit or k-ID and run underneath at close to cost, so the client gets one accountable provider instead of an SDK and a checklist.
The buyer is the platform’s head of legal or head of product. The reason to switch is access and quality rather than price: a filed, evidenced assessment in Bahasa Indonesia, priced in rupiah, carried through verification by a team answerable for the result, without hiring a new compliance team. Counsel’s observation that ratings depend on controls in place at filing [5] is why the quality of the filing, not just its existence, could be worth paying for. First customers are findable: Komdigi publishes its high-risk list [2], and industry associations such as idEA [9] and the law firms that brief platforms [5] are natural referral routes. The law firms have a reason to cooperate, because their clients keep their counsel while someone else does the implementation lawyers do not sell.
We searched in Indonesian and English for anyone advertising this managed filing service and found none; that is a search result, not proof nobody offers it. Smartlegal.id, an Indonesian online legal-services firm, writes about PP Tunas enforcement and offers general legal compliance help, though its pages do not show a PP Tunas filing service [11]. k-ID, the law firms and such legal-services firms are the closest competitors, and any of them could add the work.
One retainer against one hire
The business turns on one comparison: is a yearly retainer cheaper and better than giving the job to a staff member? Our working assumption, untested, is a retainer of Rp60–200 million a year per client covering the first filing and reassessments. Against it stands a dedicated in-house compliance lead, which we assume costs Rp15–25 million a month fully loaded, or Rp180–300 million a year; neither figure is sourced. The retainer wins clearly when filing would otherwise take a large share of a new hire. It is weaker for a platform that already employs a compliance lead, who may learn the templates from the first filing and keep the work.
The firm’s margin depends on the second relationship: how many clients one analyst can carry. If templates built for one marketplace or streaming service transfer to the next, an analyst at the same assumed Rp180–300 million a year might carry 8–12 clients, a delivery cost of roughly Rp15–38 million per client. At Rp60 million that leaves a thin margin before sales costs; at Rp100 million or more it is comfortable. These are illustrations of which numbers matter, not estimates of what the firm would earn.
The first market starts from the ministry’s own count: about 17,000 registered platforms had not filed by late June [3]. Many will be business software or services children never use. If 2–4% are domestic mid-size platforms with child-accessible products, an assumption, the first market is roughly 340–680 companies. Winning 35–75 of them at Rp80–200 million would bring in about Rp3–15 billion a year: a thin practice at the low end, a specialist firm of a few dozen people at the high end. From there the same clients face reassessment every time they ship a feature, and the same feature-level evidence work could extend to other Indonesian platform obligations; we have not sized those adjacencies.
Why platforms might still say no
The strongest objection is that the cheapest alternative keeps getting cheaper. Komdigi’s templates exist [12], k-ID’s tools are free to start [6] and its assistant drafts material for counsel [7]. A platform with one capable lawyer may decide a retainer buys little after the first filing. Enforcement cuts the other way only partly: fines cannot yet be collected [1], so some platforms will simply wait or accept a high rating. k-ID’s counsel says access blocking is already available to the ministry [5], which is a stronger stick than fines for a consumer app, but how often Komdigi will use it on a mid-size domestic service is unknown.
A rational incumbent could also respond. k-ID could add a managed tier with Indonesian partners; a law firm could hire implementers. Against that, the entrant would hold client relationships and a library of feature-to-indicator templates by the time either moved. That advantage is repeatable rather than defensible: it lowers the cost of each new filing and may raise acceptance, but it lasts only as long as the firm keeps ahead on volume. A narrower module, helping already-designated platforms change the features that drove a high rating and file again, is noted in the Research Notes; it depends on Komdigi lowering ratings after redesign, which no source yet shows.
Twenty-five priced offers
The decisive unknown is whether mid-size domestic platforms will pay before fines can be collected. The cheapest way to find out is to send a written, priced offer, a fixed filing fee plus a 12-month reassessment retainer, to 20–30 heads of legal or product at domestic platforms drawn from the high-risk list and the unfiled queue, introduced through the associations and one law firm, and ask each what its in-house plan costs. If fewer than 3 of 25 sign a letter of intent at Rp60 million or more, or most report in-house filing well below that, the business does not stand.
What is documented: the seven-aspect rule and its 58 indicators, the slow verification queue, the 17,000 unfiled platforms, the designation of domestic services as high-risk, the cheap price of age checks, and counsel’s view that the filing is a multidisciplinary job whose quality changes the rating. What is inferred: that mid-size domestic platforms lack the people to do it well. What is unknown and decisive: their willingness to pay, the real cost of doing it in-house, and how hard Komdigi will push. Trust-and-safety professionals who have filed a PP Tunas assessment, lawyers who advise platforms on it, and heads of legal at designated domestic services could answer each of those questions.
Research Notes
The sources, calculations and evidence records behind this investigation. Numbered citations in the article link here; ↩ returns to the text.
Sources and provenance. Each note gives the publisher, date, access and the claims it supports.
1. Katadata opinion, Maria Y.P. Ardianingtyas, “PP Tunas Perlu Mengukur Fitur, Bukan Sekadar Menghitung Akun”, 9 November 2026 ↩
Read in full (Indonesian). Supports: the 28 million protected accounts, the Roblox and TikTok figures, the 14 September review naming X, Meta, YouTube and TikTok; the seven aspects and 58 weighted indicators under Decree 219/2026 amending 142/2026; the one-high-aspect rule and the under-16 and 16–17 consequences; drafted fines and their dependence on a state-revenue (PNBP) government regulation; Vidio and Blibli designated high-risk; 252 PLF from 94 operators filed and 60 verified by 6 September. Opinion piece by a lawyer; the facts it reports are attributed to Komdigi.
2. Antara, “Komdigi rilis 22 platform berisiko tinggi bagi anak, ini daftarnya”, 16 September 2026 ↩
Read in full. Supports: 252 PLF from 94 operators by 6 September, 60 verified (38 low, 22 high); the full list of 22 high-risk products; the 31 December 2026 deadline; Komdigi may set an operator’s profile itself if it does not file.
3. Katadata, “17.000 Platform Digital Terancam Status Risiko Tinggi”, 29 June 2026 ↩
Read in full. Supports: about 17,000 operators holding a registration certificate (TDPSE) had not filed; 206 PLF filed by then; operators that did not file could be designated high-risk directly. The deadline it cites (30 June) was later extended (notes 2, 12).
4. k-ID, “Overview of PP Tunas’s Requirements”, 29 May 2026 ↩
Read in full. Supports: the mandatory self-assessment confirmed by Komdigi; the seven factors and single-factor rule; the age-access table; k-ID’s Compliance Studio settings configured “based on what you considered in your self-assessment”. Vendor content.
5. k-ID and Assegaf Hamzah & Partners, “Preparing for Indonesia PP Tunas. Webinar Recap”, 16 September 2026 ↩
Read (recap and transcript opening). Supports: burden of proof on the platform; features that push toward high risk; back-and-forth with Komdigi; near-identical services rated differently on controls in place at filing; Komdigi guidance advising child psychologists and IT security alongside legal, product and sales; the “village” quotation (Iqsan Sirie); fines not yet operative while access blocking is. The recap gives “2,052 products self-assessed”; Antara and Rajah & Tann give 252, which we use. Co-hosted by a vendor and a law firm that both sell PP Tunas help.
6. TechCrunch on k-ID’s launch ↩
Read. Supports: k-ID pricing “begins at free and then scales up with the number of active players per gaming title”; its gaming focus. Launch-era reporting; current pricing for non-game platforms is not published.
7. k-ID, neimo compliance assistant announcement ↩
Read. Supports: neimo answers compliance questions against rules including Indonesia’s GR 17/2025 and produces drafts and comparisons for counsel to review. It does not describe filing or handling Komdigi verification; an earlier summary describing it as an Indonesian self-assessment drafting skill was not confirmed on this page.
8. Didit, age estimation product page (Indonesian) ↩
Read in full. Supports: US$0.10 per age-estimation check; US$0.15 ID-document fallback for borderline cases; mean absolute error 1.1 years at ages 16–17.
9. Katadata, “iDEA Usul OS dan App Store Jadi Gatekeeper Verifikasi Usia”, 27 February 2026 ↩
Read. Supports: idEA’s chair warning that unclear, non-uniform technical standards raise compliance costs and burden small and mid-size firms; the proposal that operating systems and app stores verify age (not adopted).
10. Shufti Pro, “GR 17/2025 Age Compliance Checklist for Indonesian Platforms” ↩
Page title and heading read; body content did not load. Supports only that Shufti Pro markets a PP Tunas age-compliance checklist. Pricing not published.
11. Smartlegal.id, “Sanksi Google: Bukti Ketegasan Komdigi Tegakkan PP Tunas”, 20 April 2026 ↩
Read. An Indonesian online legal-services firm (trademarks, company formation, licensing, consultation) explaining PP Tunas obligations and closing with a general offer of legal compliance solutions. No PP Tunas filing service or price is shown; whether it sells one is unknown.
12. Rajah & Tann Asia client update on the PP Tunas self-assessment extension, 1 October 2026 ↩
Read. Supports: Decrees 142/2026 and 219/2026 supply indicators, templates and verification procedures; the deadline extended to 31 December 2026; obligations not suspended; Komdigi may assess non-filers itself; 252 PLF from 94 operators filed and 60 verified by 6 September; draft fines of up to 6% of global revenue.
Reporting from Bisnis.com on industry requests for more time, verification tariffs and filing counts, and a pajak.com note on identity-check fees, appeared in the research but could not be opened (access blocked); they are not used.
Competitors and substitutes
| Name | Offering | Pricing | Segment and channel | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| k-ID | Age assurance, parental consent, market rules; neimo AI drafts for counsel | Starts free, scales with active players per game | Game and app developers globally; developer self-serve, webinars with a local law firm | [4][5][6][7] |
| Didit | Facial age estimation with ID fallback | US$0.10 per check; US$0.15 fallback | Developers of any size; self-serve | [8] |
| Shufti Pro | Identity and age verification; PP Tunas checklist | Not published | Global platforms; enterprise sales | [10] |
| Assegaf Hamzah & Partners and other law firms | Interpretation, briefings, filing strategy | Not published | Large domestic and foreign operators; relationships | [5] |
| Smartlegal.id | General online legal services; PP Tunas commentary | No PP Tunas fee found | Indonesian businesses; content marketing | [11] |
| Local identity-check firms (e.g. VIDA, Privy, Verihubs) | ID checks against the national population register | Not verified here | Finance; enterprise sales | Background only |
| In-house lead with ministry templates | Own filing | Staff time (unsourced) | Every operator | [12] |
| Do the minimum | Accept high-risk rating, close under-16 accounts | Lost teen users | Designated and unfiled operators | [1][2] |
Search for operators already running a managed filing service: “jasa konsultan kepatuhan PP Tunas self-assessment platform PSE” and “managed PP 17/2025 child protection compliance service Indonesia risk assessment filing Komdigi consultancy”. Neither found an advertised managed filing service. k-ID, Shufti Pro and Smartlegal.id are treated as possibly present until a source settles it; the thesis was restated against each (sell the accepted rating, buy verification from the vendors, partner with or compete against legal-services firms on implementation) and holds.
Evidence ledger
Observed: the rule structure and consequences (1, 2, 4, 12); the verification backlog (1, 2, 12); 17,000 unfiled (3); domestic high-risk designations (1, 2); age-check prices (6, 8); fines pending (1, 12). Reported by interested parties: that the filing needs a multidisciplinary team and that controls in place change the rating (5, vendor and law firm). Inferred: mid-size domestic operators lack the people to file well. Hypothesis: they would pay an outside team. Unknown: the cost of in-house filing; the share of the 17,000 that are child-accessible domestic mid-size operators; whether Komdigi lowers a rating after redesign.
Economics workings
Retainer: Rp60–200 million per client-year (assumption, to be tested by the priced offer). In-house comparator: one dedicated lead at Rp15–25 million a month fully loaded = Rp180–300 million a year (assumption; the weakest input). Delivery: analyst at the same assumed cost carrying 8–12 clients = Rp180m/12 ≈ Rp15m to Rp300m/8 ≈ Rp38m per client-year, plus pass-through verification at US$0.10 a check (8). Contribution before sales cost (illustration): at Rp60m, Rp22–45m (37–75%); at Rp200m, Rp162–185m (81–92%). Acquisition cost unknown: founder-led B2B sales from public lists and referrals. Beachhead: 17,000 unfiled (3) × 2–4% domestic mid-size child-accessible (assumption) = 340–680 operators; × Rp60–200m = Rp20–136 billion a year spend if all bought; capturable 35–75 clients × Rp80–200m ≈ Rp3–15 billion a year (assumption). Weakest inputs: the 2–4% share and the in-house cost.
Strategy details
Komdigi-ready PP Tunas compliance service (featured). Workflow: feature inventory; scoring against 58 indicators with evidence; feature-change advice; filing; handling clarification until determination; reassessment on feature change. Partners: verification vendors (paid volume from domestic clients they do not reach), law firms (referrals; clients keep counsel), associations (members asked for clearer rules). Team: trust-and-safety or privacy analysts, a technical lead; small capital. Test: priced offer to 20–30 operators; comparator their in-house plan; falsified if fewer than 3 of 25 sign at Rp60 million or more.
Designation-triggered feature redesign (peer). For products already rated high-risk: diagnose which aspect drove the rating, prescribe changes such as contact limits and safer defaults, support implementation and file again; project fee, optionally a success fee. Small segment (22 designated products so far, not all domestic) and best run as a module of the featured service. Decisive assumption: Komdigi lowers a designated product’s rating after redesign. Test: ask the ministry and 5–8 designated domestic platforms whether any rating has been lowered and whether they intend to seek one.
Routes considered
Fixed-fee rupiah retainers, analyst-delivered filing, one vendor for checks and filing, per-aspect templates, association, law-firm and accounting-firm referral channels: folded into the featured service. A benchmark of verified feature sets and designation-triggered outreach: folded into the redesign module. Rejected: code-connected compliance toggles and CI scanners (the indicators judge product behaviour, not code); continuous telemetry auto-filing and provisional low-risk status (need channels or rule changes only Komdigi can create); planning-stage plugins, ticket routing and deploy gates (no evidenced bottleneck); cheaper or periodic age verification and combined age-and-consent tokens (age checks are already cheap and bundled by k-ID and Didit).
Open questions
How much does an in-house filing cost a mid-size operator? How many of the 17,000 are domestic, mid-size and child-accessible? When will the fines regulation be issued, and how often will Komdigi block access? Has any rating been lowered after redesign? Would k-ID or a law firm launch a managed local tier?
Leave a Reply