A cashew nut grows on a tree, inside a hard shell. Growers in Dompu, a district on Sumbawa island in West Nusa Tenggara province, dry the nuts in the sun and sell them in the shell to traders; the money comes in the end from processors, who crack the nuts and sell the kernels as snacks, and from exporters. This year the Agriculture Ministry is backing the replanting of 754 hectares of old, diseased cashew orchards in Dompu with seedlings, fertiliser and technical advice [1]. A replanted tree earns nothing until it bears. The district’s plantation official says the programme will succeed only if the trees are looked after until then, and some growers have already moved to maize, which pays within a season [1].
That suggests a business: a company that buys the growers’ nuts and spends part of its trading margin on looking after their orchards. We tested it against the prices we could find. On those prices the answer is no, because the margin it would spend does not appear to exist.
Trees that pay nothing until they bear
The replanting is spread over four sub-districts, with half of it, 377 hectares, in Pekat [1]. Farmer groups receive the seedlings and fertiliser. What the programme does not supply is the continuing work on young trees, chiefly weeding and pruning in the first years [7], or an income while they grow. The official’s advice is to plant other crops between the rows, or keep livestock, until the cashew bears [1].
The orchards that still produce are not doing well either. The Agriculture Ministry’s provisional figures for 2025 put West Nusa Tenggara’s crop at 8,822 tonnes from 25,150 producing hectares: 351 kilos a hectare, against 508 nationally [3].
So the problem is simple to state: nobody pays for upkeep on a tree that is not yet bearing, and a household that needs cash this season has a faster crop to turn to. No source we found puts a rupiah figure on the cost of that upkeep or on the income a Dompu household gives up while it waits.
Who buys Dompu’s cashew now
A company that wants to pay for upkeep out of cashew trading has to take a place in the trade, so it matters who is already there.
How a grower’s cashew reaches a buyer
- 1. Grower
Dries the nuts in the sun and sells them in the shell at harvest, about August to November - 2. Village collector
Buys by the kilo at the grower’s home with cash, sometimes advanced before harvest; historically funded by an exporter and paid 10% of purchase value - 3. District collector or inter-island trader
Gathers lots and works for, or sells to, traders and exporters - 4. Exporter or large processor
Ships raw nuts abroad or cracks them; supplies the buying capital - 5. The direct route
A small local processor buys from partner growers itself and skips the collectors
The main route runs through collectors. A 2015 study of the province’s cashew trade by PRISMA, a farm-income programme supported by the Australian government, described village collectors buying nuts by the kilo at growers’ homes, sometimes paying part in advance in June or July and deducting it at harvest, which runs from about August to November. They passed the nuts to district collectors, who worked for or sold to traders and exporters. In Dompu, the study said, the representative of one Indian company bought up to 80% of the district’s crop this way, and prices agreed with collectors were generally considered fair and competitive [7].
An earlier study by Universitas Mataram, the state university in the provincial capital, interviewed the trade in Pekat and in Bayan on neighbouring Lombok, using 2009 data. Export companies gave each village collector Rp100–200 million of buying capital at harvest and paid the collector 10% of the value of the nuts bought. The companies trusted collectors because they knew the quality the company wanted; growers took the price they were offered [6]. Both studies are old, and we found no description of today’s terms. What they show is that the job a new buying company would do, standing in the village with cash on behalf of a large buyer, has been done for a long time by people the large buyers pay and finance.
The second route skips the collector. KWT Bangkit Bersama is a ten-member women’s farming group in Sugian, East Lombok, that makes cashew snacks. It buys raw nuts through partnerships with growers in its own sub-district and in North Lombok, 200 to 300 kilos for each production run. In July 2026 its chair told the Lombok Post that the raw material cost Rp25,000 a kilo, the highest in years, and was expected to reach Rp30,000; in earlier years it had been about Rp15,000 [2]. That is the only record we found of what a buyer in the province pays for raw cashew this year.
There are also trading desks. SourcID, a commodity trading desk that sources in Indonesia, advertises buying from farmer cooperatives and local traders, testing each lot and exporting by the container, with a minimum order of one container, about 16–17 tonnes of nuts in shell. Its supplier page says that registering is not a purchase order or a promise of finance, and its listed origins are Sulawesi, Flores, Bali and Java, not Sumbawa [4] [5].
A buyer that pays for upkeep
The business we examined would work like this. During the harvest its field buyers visit growers whose older trees still bear, weigh the dried nuts and pay cash. The company checks the nuts for moisture and size, bags them and trucks them to a processor or an export buyer. From each kilo it sells, it sets aside a small amount, and after the harvest it spends that money on the same growers’ orchards: pruning, weeding and care for young trees. The grower gets a buyer who also helps keep the orchard alive. The processor gets checked nuts without sending its own people to the villages. The company lives on the difference between what it pays and what it is paid.
The research that prompted this article put numbers on one kilo. All of them were assumptions: buy from the grower at Rp20,000; spend Rp1,000 on freight and storage, Rp500 on checking and weight lost in drying, Rp300 on the cost of money tied up during the season and Rp500 on running the company; set aside Rp700 for upkeep. That is about Rp23,000. Sell at Rp24,000, just under the Rp25,000 the Sugian group reported, and Rp1,000 a kilo is left.
The same kilo, priced twice
The flaw is in how that Rp25,000 was read. The model treated it as the price a new supplier could sell under. But the Sugian group buys from growers. Rp25,000 is what growers there are being paid [2].
Run the kilo again on that footing. A grower who can get Rp25,000 from a buyer who deals direct has no reason to accept Rp20,000 from a newcomer. If the newcomer pays Rp25,000 and its other costs are unchanged, the kilo arrives at the processor costing about Rp28,000, on our calculation. The processor pays Rp25,000 today by buying direct.
What one kilo of raw cashew costs a processor
Someone has to lose. Either the grower is paid less than the direct buyer pays, or the processor pays more than it does now. The upkeep does not make up the difference for the grower. At Rp700 a kilo and 351 kilos a hectare, it comes to about Rp250,000 a hectare a year [3]. Selling the same hectare’s nuts at Rp20,000 a kilo instead of Rp25,000 gives up about Rp1.75 million.
There is a fair objection. Rp25,000 is one small buyer on Lombok in an unusually expensive year; collectors in Dompu may pay less, and a buyer of whole containers may pay more. Indonesia exported 70,127 tonnes of cashew worth US$129.3 million in the first eleven months of 2025 [3], so there is money further along the chain. But the place between Dompu’s growers and those export buyers is already taken by the collectors the exporters finance. A newcomer selling to exporters would be one more collector, earning something like the collector’s commission, and nothing we found shows it doing that job more cheaply. A comparison of the two figures we do have points the same way: the Sugian group’s price in earlier years, about Rp15,000, is close to the national average for dry cashew in shell, Rp15,483 in 2025 [3]. We infer from this that buyers who deal direct pay roughly the going farm price, not a marked-up one that leaves room for a middleman.
We tried one change to rescue the idea: pay growers the full Rp25,000 and sell only to export buyers who pay more. It fails on the evidence available. No price paid by an export buyer for nuts from this province was found, and those buyers have their own funded collectors.
Three prices from one week
So could a cashew buyer pay for orchard upkeep in Dompu? Not on the prices found. What is documented: the replanting and its gap, a processor paying growers Rp25,000 a kilo, and a collecting trade that exporters have long paid for and financed. What we infer: that direct buyers pay about the going farm price, and that a newcomer’s kilo would cost a processor about Rp3,000 more than buying direct. What we do not know is what collectors in Dompu are paying this season. Four searches for a current farm price in Dompu, Bima or Lombok found none, which is not evidence that prices there match Lombok’s.
That unknown is cheap to settle. Three numbers from the same week of a Dompu harvest would do it: what collectors pay growers for dried nuts, what a buyer of container-sized lots pays for nuts it accepts, and what it costs to truck and check them in between. If the gap between the first two is well above Rp3,000 a kilo, and one named buyer says it would take nuts from a new supplier, the idea deserves a second look. A collector, a trader shipping between the islands, an exporter’s buying agent or a farmer group in the replanting programme could supply those numbers.
The growers’ problem remains. The upkeep and income gap on 754 hectares is real, and the evidence says cashew trading is not where the money to close it will come from.
Research Notes
The sources, calculations and evidence records behind this investigation. Numbered citations in the article link here; ↩ returns to the text.
Sources
1. Kementan dukung peremajaan 754 hektare kebun mete di Dompu ↩
ANTARA news agency, 2026. Read in full. Supports the 754 hectares, the four sub-districts and their areas, the inputs supplied, the old and diseased trees, the switch to maize, the official’s remarks on upkeep and on planting other crops or keeping livestock. It gives no prices, incomes or upkeep costs, and does not say how long the trees take to bear.
2. Melihat Kreativitas KWT Bangkit Bersama Desa Sugian ↩
Lombok Post, 27 July 2026. Read in full. A report from the group’s premises quoting its chair. Supports the ten members, the grower partnerships in Sambelia and North Lombok, Rp25,000 a kilo now, an expected Rp30,000, about Rp15,000 in earlier years, and 200–300 kilos a run. Limits: one small buyer on Lombok, not Dompu; the article does not state moisture, grade or whether the price includes delivery.
3. Laporan Kinerja Direktorat Jenderal Perkebunan 2025 ↩
Directorate General of Estate Crops, Ministry of Agriculture, March 2026. Cashew section read (printed pages 219–222, Tables 74–76). 2025 figures are provisional: West Nusa Tenggara 8,822 tonnes from 25,150 producing hectares (351 kg/ha); national 135,764 tonnes (508 kg/ha). National average domestic price for dry nuts in shell: Rp15,483 a kilo in 2025, between Rp14,092 and Rp16,995 in 2020–2024. Exports to November 2025: 70,127 tonnes worth US$129.3 million, raw nuts and kernels combined, so the total does not give a clean price per kilo of raw nuts.
4. Supply Cashew to SourcID: Producer & Processor Offtake Network ↩
The company’s own supplier page, read in full; everything taken from it is advertised, not measured. Supports the supplier types it invites, the statement that submitting information is not a purchase order, guaranteed volume or advance financing, and the origins named (Sulawesi, Flores, Bali, Java). No prices.
5. Cashew Sourcing from Indonesia: Export Specifications & Supply ↩
The company’s own commodity page, read in part; advertised. Supports lot evaluation, cutting tests and container export, the minimum order of one 20-foot container (about 16–17 tonnes in shell), a moisture limit of 8.5–9% and 180–200 nuts a kilo. Quotes on request only.
6. Model kemitraan yang berkesinambungan pada industri mete di kawasan perkebunan jambu mete Nusa Tenggara Barat ↩
Anwar, Dipokusumo and Miharja, Universitas Mataram, in the journal Agrimansion. Relevant sections read. Survey and interviews in Bayan (Lombok) and Pekat (Dompu); tables dated 2009, so historical. Supports the Rp100–200 million of buying capital, the 10% incentive, collectors as the exporter’s field arm, purchase guarantees of Rp150–300 million to traders shipping between islands, and growers taking the price set.
7. Cashew Growth Strategy Document for Nusa Tenggara Barat ↩
PRISMA, October 2015. Sector description read. Historical. Supports the collection chain, advances in June–July, harvest from about August/September to November, the Indian company’s representative in Dompu buying up to 80% of the district’s production, prices “generally considered fair and competitive”, and a price range of Rp8,000–18,000 a kilo at the time.
Competitors and substitutes
| Who | What they do | Price or terms | How we know |
|---|---|---|---|
| Village and district collectors | Buy at the farm with cash, sometimes with advances; gather and transport | Current margin not found; historically 10% of purchase value from the exporter | Sources 6 and 7, both historical |
| Exporters and traders who finance collectors | Supply seasonal buying capital, then process or export | Not published | Sources 6 and 7, historical; names and current terms not established |
| Processors buying direct (KWT Bangkit Bersama) | Buy raw nuts from partner growers for their own snacks | Rp25,000/kg reported July 2026 | Source 2 |
| SourcID | Advertises buying, lot testing and container export | Quote on request; minimum one container | Sources 4 and 5, the seller’s own pages |
| YAVA / East Bali Cashews | Reported to buy from growers near its Bali factory for its own snack brand | Not found | Search results only; not verified and not relied on |
| Maize and other seasonal crops | Income within a season on the same land | No per-hectare comparison in the sources | Source 1 |
| The programme plus the grower’s own labour | Free inputs and advice; the household does the upkeep | No fee | Source 1 |
Evidence ledger
Observed: the replanting and what it supplies [1]; growers switching to maize [1]; one processor’s price to growers [2]; provincial output, yield, the national average price and export totals [3]. Observed, historical: exporter-financed collecting in Pekat and Bayan [6]; one buyer taking most of Dompu’s crop [7]. Inferred: that direct buyers pay about the going farm price; that a newcomer has no margin on sales to processors of the Sugian kind. Not found: a current price paid by collectors in Dompu; a price paid by any buyer of container lots for nuts from the province; the cost of orchard upkeep per hectare; the number of processors and exporters buying the province’s nuts. A competing explanation we cannot rule out: 2026 prices may be high everywhere, in which case the gap between collector and volume buyer could be wider or narrower than in a normal year.
Economics workings
The research’s kilo (all assumptions): purchase Rp20,000 + freight and storage Rp1,000 + checking and drying loss Rp500 + upkeep Rp700 + seasonal capital Rp300 + buying and administration Rp500 = Rp23,000; assumed selling price Rp24,000; Rp1,000 left.
Redone (our calculation): purchase Rp25,000 (the one sourced input [2]) + the same Rp3,000 of assumed costs = Rp28,000, against Rp25,000 for the processor’s direct purchase. Dropping the upkeep entirely still leaves Rp27,300. The weakest input is the purchase price: it is one buyer’s figure, on Lombok, with moisture and delivery terms unstated.
Upkeep: Rp700/kg × 351 kg/ha [3] = Rp245,700 per hectare a year. Price difference: Rp5,000/kg × 351 kg/ha = Rp1,755,000 per hectare.
First market: the only counted base is the province’s crop, 8,822 tonnes a year [3]. The research built its first market from buyers: 2–4 processor or exporter accounts × 6 orders in a harvest × 16 tonnes an order = 192–384 tonnes a year. All three inputs are assumptions; no count of such buyers was found, and the one observed buyer takes 200–300 kilos a run. At the research’s Rp1,000 a kilo that would leave Rp192–384 million a year before fixed costs it assumed at about Rp150 million. On the redone kilo there is nothing left to multiply. The research’s wider market figures (a national market of Rp2.7–3.4 trillion a year at Rp20,000–25,000 a kilo) are context only.
Buying direct instead: a processor can already buy from growers itself, as the Sugian group does; there is no asset to own, so no breakeven applies.
Routes considered
Nineteen variations on the buying company were reviewed. None changes the comparison above, and none is featured.
- Drying (shared drying sites, on-farm drying premiums, mobile or small dryers, drying mats, payment tied to moisture): the research’s whole allowance for checking and drying loss is an assumed Rp500 a kilo, so removing it all leaves the newcomer about Rp2,500 behind, and equipment adds cost. Buyers’ published specifications already expect sun-dried nuts under 9% moisture [4] [5].
- Payment (same-day mobile payouts, staged payments, village-shop drop-off points, spot settlement): these change when the grower is paid, not the price; collectors already pay cash at the farm [6] [7].
- Working capital (finance from truckers, lenders or warehouse receipts, released in stages): at best this trims an assumed Rp300 a kilo, and exporters already finance collectors’ buying [6].
- Fixing grade and price before harvest; blending lots to a guaranteed specification; field agents who verify upkeep: each adds cost to a trade with no shown margin; lot testing is already advertised by trading desks [4] [5], and verification would have to be paid from about Rp250,000 a hectare.
Open questions
What do collectors in Pekat, Kempo, Manggelewa and Pajo pay growers this season, and on what terms? What does a buyer of container lots pay for accepted nuts from Sumbawa, and does it finance its own collectors today? What does a year of upkeep on a hectare of young cashew cost, and who besides the grower has a reason to pay for it? A collector or exporter’s agent could answer the first two; the Dompu plantation office or a farmer group in the programme could answer the third.
Leave a Reply