Could a solar ice company sell to fish collectors at Maluku’s remote landings?

In Sinaka, a fishing village in the Mentawai islands off West Sumatra, the fish collector Idris Maulana spends about Rp1.8 million each week on one trip: a boat run to Sikakap, the next harbour town, to buy ice and the fuel to bring it back. At most Idris needs about 400 kilograms a week, and the trip is needed because Sinaka’s own ice plant often stops working [8]. Fuel included, that is roughly Rp4,500 a kilogram, about 27 US cents. Ice is what keeps a small boat’s catch saleable: without it, fish and octopus spoil before they reach a buyer. A collector is the trader who buys fish from small boats and often supplies the fishers with ice and fuel on credit, so the collector usually pays for the ice.

Far to the east, in Kawa, a village in Maluku province, a container of solar panels and freezing equipment has made about 16 tonnes of ice a month since late 2024, and more than 176 tonnes in its first year [4]. So the machine works. The question this article answers is whether a new company could make money selling that ice to collectors at remote landings, rather than giving machines away.

Where the ice comes from today

Ice is made by freezing water in moulds into large blocks, and the freezers need steady electricity around the clock. Many small islands have power only part of the day, or none, so no ice can be made there. Collectors and fishers solve this in three ways. They make ice in home freezers, which melts when the power goes out: a Kawa tuna fisher, Yadi Bustan, told an industry publication that before the solar plant came, fishers often had to go back to shore without a catch, and still paid for the electricity and plastic bags [4]. They fetch ice by boat from a town plant: on Pagerungan Kecil, an island in East Java, fishers ride an hour by speedboat and pay Rp4,000 a kilogram at the plant [2]. Or they sell the catch at once, at whatever price is offered [3].

How ice reaches a small boat today, and what would change

  1. 1. Town ice plant
    Freezes blocks on grid or diesel power; sells at the plant
  2. 2. Collector fetches
    Pays for the ice plus boat fuel and a day’s trip
  3. 3. Fishers take ice on credit
    Chill the catch at sea so it stays saleable
  4. 4. Collector buys the catch
    Settles the ice and fuel credit against the fish
  5. 5. Proposed: plant at the landing
    Collector buys weighed ice locally; no trip
Today the collector fetches ice from a town plant; Landing Ice Network would replace the first two steps with a plant at the landing.Based on sources [2] [4] [8] and our own reasoning.

Even the town plants run short. In Sikka, on Flores in East Nusa Tenggara (NTT), fishers complained this month that they could not get ice; the district fisheries office said each government plant makes about 10 tonnes a day and sells blocks for Rp15,000 each [19]. The office did not give the weight of a block, so that price cannot be turned into a price per kilogram.

The mechanism is simple. Where power fails and nobody keeps an ice plant running, a collector pays the distant plant for the ice and also pays for the fuel and the day on a boat it takes to fetch it. A plant at the landing would remove the trip, but its machine costs the same whether collectors buy much ice or little, so it must sell enough during the fishing year to pay back the equipment and the people who run it. Whether one landing buys that much is what decides the business.

Who already makes ice from sunshine

A newcomer would not be first. The Kawa plant was built by AIREF, an Indonesian refrigeration research group, with GIZ (Germany’s development agency), the fisheries charity IPNLF, the tuna company ASTB and the Maluku fisheries office; local people were trained to run and repair it [4]. GIZ reports a second unit in Sulamu, near Kupang in NTT, and is now trying to make the machine a commercial product [3] [14]. NUSACUBE, a start-up run by PT Alana Green Electric, operates two solar ice units on Pagerungan Kecil making up to 900 kilograms a day, and has grant money for a pilot on nearby Sadulang Besar [2]. We found no record of NUSACUBE in Maluku, but that does not show it is absent.

The largest player is the government. The fisheries ministry, KKP, is building Kampung Nelayan Merah Putih (KNMP), modern fishing villages with ice plants and cold stores, run by village cooperatives with support teams and managers seconded from PT Agrinas Jaladri Nusantara, a state company [9] [11] [18]. One such cooperative, at Labetawi near Tual in Maluku, is already running with an outside investor [17]. Subsidised ice can be very cheap: an earlier state fishing village at Biak in Papua sold ice for Rp800 a kilogram in 2023 [6]. We found no current KNMP ice price in Maluku. And on 10 November, the state power company PLN said more than 10,000 Indonesian villages still need electricity and that remote ones would get solar power with batteries; speakers at the same forum pointed to ice for fishers as one use [1].

So a private company could only work where none of these reach: landings with no working plant, no funded KNMP plan and no donor unit nearby.

Landing Ice Network: what it would sell

The business we examined, Landing Ice Network, would build and run solar ice plants at such landings and sell ice by the kilogram to the collectors already there. One sale would go like this. Before building anything, the company’s regional team checks a landing’s dated ice receipts and catch records, weighs the blocks collectors buy today, and asks several collectors for written orders at a set price. If the orders cover the plant, it signs a lease with the landowner or village cooperative and installs a containerised plant. Two paid local staff freeze clean water and keep the blocks in insulated storage. A collector comes to the plant, the staff weigh the ice they take, and the collector pays our assumed price of Rp2,750 a kilogram, about 17 US cents. The collector then hands the ice to the fishers who sell their catch to the collector, on the same credit terms as now. Staff record each sale and do routine checks; a technician who covers several islands handles real repairs, with spare parts held in the region.

Related Business Opportunity:  What if poultry farmers could see what cleaning chick house leaves behind?

The collector gains on price and access: Rp2,750 at their own landing against roughly Rp4,000–4,500 for fetched ice in the two places where we found a price, and no lost day on the water fetching it. Fishers gain on quality: ice that lasts lets them stay out longer, which Kawa fishers report [4]. Neither of those reference prices is from Maluku, and we found no record of what Maluku collectors pay today per kilogram. That is the first thing the company would have to establish.

How much ice each plant must sell

A plant’s costs barely change with how much ice it sells: the equipment must be paid off, the staff paid and the spares bought whether collectors turn up or not. So volume decides whether a plant pays. On our assumptions, one plant costs about Rp340 million a year to keep (repaying the non-solar equipment over eight years, two local wages, spare parts, a share of the regional technicians and sales staff, land, water and insurance), plus about Rp500 for the solar power behind each kilogram. The freezing machine alone is advertised at Rp233 million before tax [15]; the rest are our estimates, built in Research Notes.

At Kawa’s first-year output of 176 tonnes sold at Rp2,750, a plant would take in about Rp480 million and keep about Rp50 million a year, around a tenth of sales. It breaks even at about 150 tonnes. At 100 tonnes it loses more than Rp100 million.

One plant’s year at different sales volumes

Ice sold in a year Sales Result before tax
100 tonnes about Rp275 million loss of about Rp118 million
153 tonnes about Rp420 million break-even
176 tonnes (Kawa’s first-year output) about Rp484 million surplus of about Rp52 million
Central case at an assumed Rp2,750 a kilogram, with about Rp340 million of fixed cost and about Rp500 of power per kilogram.Estimate based on sources [4] [12] [15] [16].

The weak link is buyers. A collector like Idris, buying 400 kilograms in each of 40 to 52 fishing weeks, takes 16 to 21 tonnes a year. To break even, a plant needs about seven to ten collectors of that size, or a few much larger ones, buying at one landing; to match Kawa’s 176 tonnes, about nine to eleven. Kawa does not settle this: the reports count ice produced, not ice sold, and Kawa’s ice also goes to neighbouring communities [4], so nobody has shown that a single landing buys 150 tonnes.

Why not let the collectors own the plant?

The strongest argument against the company is that the collectors could club together and buy the same plant. A single collector cannot: 20 tonnes a year will never pay for it. A group of collectors or a cooperative is different. Owning the same plant, it would skip the company’s regional overhead and profit but pay an outside technician, say Rp30 million a year, for a yearly cost of about Rp280 million plus power. On those figures the group’s own plant is cheaper than buying the company’s ice once the group uses more than about 126 tonnes a year, and at 176 tonnes the company charges roughly Rp340 a kilogram more than the group would spend. What the company offers for that markup is the money up front (about Rp480–630 million per site, depending on site work and shipping, before the solar system, which an investor or lender would have to fund), someone accountable for keeping the plant running, and the risk of a bad season moved off the collectors. Kawa shows that trained villagers can run a plant themselves [4], and state and donor money makes ownership cheaper still. Town plants could also cut prices or deliver ice on the supply boats.

So the answer to the title is: possibly, at a minority of landings. A company could sell solar ice to Maluku collectors where at least nine or ten regular buyers gather, no subsidised plant is coming and nobody local wants to own the machine. Whether such landings exist in useful numbers is unknown.

The size of the first market

Maluku has 1,074 villages on the coast, according to national statistics [7]. That counts villages, not landings with enough collectors. We narrowed it with three assumed shares: 20–35% of those villages lack dependable ice; of those, 15–25% have enough paying buyers and a route a technician can reach; and 70–90% of those stay free of funded state or donor plants. That is 1,074 × 20–35% × 15–25% × 70–90%, or about 23 to 85 possible sites. The shares are guesses for a site survey to replace. A company running four to six plants in its second year would sell about Rp2–3 billion of ice a year. Growing to 12 to 18 plants across Maluku, North Maluku (946 coastal villages) and NTT (1,019) by year five would mean about Rp6–9 billion a year in sales and, on our central case, under Rp1 billion a year in profit before tax. That is a small regional company, not a national one.

Related Business Opportunity:  Could pooled early orders make certified rice seed cheaper for Indramayu's farmer groups?

What would settle it

Documented: solar ice plants work in Maluku and NTT, collectors elsewhere pay Rp4,000–4,500 a kilogram for fetched ice, and the state is building cooperative-run plants. Inferred: a plant needs about 150 tonnes of paid sales a year at Rp2,750 to break even. Unknown and decisive: what Maluku collectors pay today, whether enough of them gather at one unserved landing, the full installed cost of a plant, and whether they would rather pay a markup than own the plant together.

The cheapest test is a month at one candidate landing: read collectors’ ice receipts, weigh the blocks, offer a written price, and get one complete installed-and-serviced quote to set beside the cost of a collector group owning the same plant. If written orders fall short of about 150 tonnes a year, or the group’s own plant comes out clearly cheaper, the company should not build. Collectors, cooperative boards, refrigeration installers and the GIZ and AIREF teams could each answer part of this.

What has to be true

The business described above stands on these claims, listed in the order we would test them.

  1. Enough Maluku collectors will pay about Rp2,750/kg for at least 153 tonnes a year at each site.
    Not yet tested · Fish collectors
    One Mentawai collector reports up to about 400 kg/week; Kawa reports 176 t/year produced, not contracted Maluku demand. [4] [8] [19]
    Would break if: Season-adjusted paid commitments fall below the quoted site break-even volume.
    Cheapest test: Check twelve months of ice receipts and catch records, weigh blocks, and make a priced supply offer before commissioning equipment.
  2. A serviceable cluster of eligible Maluku landings remains after funded state and donor catchments are removed.
    Not yet tested · Cooperatives and local permission holders
    [3] [9] [17]
    Would break if: A site list shows too few high-volume unserved landings to fill the first four to six operating sites.
    Cheapest test: Cross-check local landing lists against funded KNMP plans, donor coverage, actual ice supply and sailing routes.
  3. Buyers value an operated supply enough to prefer it over pooling money and owning the same plant.
    Not yet tested · Fish collectors
    [4] [15]
    Would break if: A funded collector group can own and operate reliably for less, and will not pay the service premium.
    Cheapest test: Quote a cooperative-owned equivalent including service, financing and paid management; compare with a priced ice contract.
  4. A complete off-grid installation can supply ice within the modelled capital, power and repair allowances.
    Not yet tested · Equipment and solar suppliers
    [1] [14] [15] [16]
    Would break if: Matched installed quotes and seasonal yields push full cost above the accepted selling price.
    Cheapest test: Get one integrated machine/PV/water/storage quote with yield, battery replacement, salt exposure, shipping and service terms.
  5. Landowners and cooperatives will permit a paid private ice service despite the prospect of a subsidised plant.
    Not yet tested · Cooperative / landowner / local permission holders
    [1] [9] [18]
    Would break if: No viable lease and permission route survives a funded KNMP arrival or competing land use.
    Cheapest test: Ask for a conditional site lease and written asset, water and permit requirements after checking funded public plans.
  6. A capital provider will finance the initial sites without a guarantee that collectors or processors cannot afford.
    Not yet tested · Capital provider
    [1]
    Would break if: Financing terms raise annual capital cost above the sales margin or require unavailable guarantees.
    Cheapest test: Take verified priced demand, the installed quote and a four-site cash-flow case to a lender or equity provider.
  7. Suppliers will support remote installations at the quoted lifecycle cost and paid local staff can sustain output.
    Not yet tested · Equipment and solar suppliers / local staff
    [4] [14] [16]
    Would break if: Weather, failures or maintenance costs reduce saleable output below break-even.
    Cheapest test: Check actual Kawa maintenance and paid-sales logs, then obtain written parts, training and repair arrangements.
  8. The sales and installation teams can acquire, retain and commission the modelled sites within the buying season.
    Not yet tested · Capital provider / operating team
    [1] [4]
    Would break if: Commissioning delays, lost accounts or simultaneous peak demand make the active-site assumptions unattainable.
    Cheapest test: Verify access to one cluster and obtain priced installer schedules; count paid months and seasonal demand for each signed site.

Research Notes

The sources, calculations and evidence records behind this investigation. Numbered citations in the article link here; ↩ returns to the text.

Sources

[1] detikFinance, “Program PLTS 100 GWp Dibidik untuk Terangi 10.000 Desa”, November 2026. Read in full. PLN’s statement on more than 10,000 villages without electricity and battery-backed solar for remote ones; ADB’s Sun2Sea plan for solar ice and fish storage; the solar industry association AESI’s estimate of about 29 US cents per kWh for solar generation in fishing villages (an estimate, not a tariff). ↩

Related Business Opportunity:  Could a regional dairy plant supply fresh milk to Java's free school-meal kitchens?

[2] New Energy Nexus Indonesia, “NUSACUBE by PT Alana Green Electric”, 22 December 2025. Read in full. Pagerungan Kecil fishers’ one-hour speedboat trip and Rp4,000/kg ice; two NUSACUBE units in operation (up to 900 kg/day); the planned Sadulang Besar pilot. Written by the programme that funded the company. ↩

[3] GIZ, “Towards the Commercialization of Solar Ice Makers”, 20 April 2026. Read in full. Fishers forced to sell immediately at lower prices without ice; pilots in Kupang (NTT) and West Seram (Maluku); the commercialisation effort. ↩

[4] Global Seafood Alliance, Responsible Seafood Advocate, “A revolution in the making”, 8 December 2025. Read in full. Kawa plant partners, local training, more than 176 t produced in the first year, about 16 t a month, supply to neighbouring communities, Yadi Bustan’s account. Figures are reported by the project partners; paid sales and prices are not given. ↩

[6] Cabinet Secretariat, opening of the Biak Numfor modern fishing village, 23 November 2023. Read in full. The President’s remarks on a small, cooperative-run ice plant selling cheaply (Rp800/kg in that 2023 example) and on idle cold stores that could not pay for electricity. Historical; not a current KNMP price. ↩

[7] GoodStats, “10 Provinsi dengan Desa di Tepi Laut Terbanyak 2025”, citing BPS. Read in full. Coastal villages in 2025: Maluku 1,074, NTT 1,019, North Maluku 946. The BPS table itself opened but did not render its data. Counts villages, not landings or collectors. ↩

[8] Mongabay Indonesia, “Perikanan Mentawai Terkendala Kesediaan Es Batu”, 13 October 2026. Read in full. Idris Maulana: “keluarkan biaya Rp1,8 juta untuk sekali beli es batu dan bahan bakar dari Sinaka ke Sikakap. ‘Itu setiap satu minggu. Kebutuhan es paling banyak 2 fiber atau sekitar 400 kilogram dalam satu minggu’”. Collectors spend Rp1.5–1.8 million a week; Sinaka’s plant often stops. Mentawai, not Maluku. ↩

[9] CNBC Indonesia, KKP on the Kampung Nelayan Merah Putih programme, 17 November 2026. Read in full. Current scale and plans of the state fishing-village programme. ↩

[11] Investortrust, “65 Kampung Nelayan Merah Putih Kirim 273,6 Ton Ikan”, 24 August 2026. Read in full. KNMP villages operating and shipping fish, including in Maluku. ↩

[12] Dealls, “UMP Maluku 2026”. Read in full. Maluku’s 2026 provincial minimum wage of Rp3,334,490 a month, used as the wage reference. ↩

[13] KKP, Directorate General of Capture Fisheries, 2024 performance report. Section read (PDF pp. 40–41). Capture-fisheries production context for the market-size range; not used for prices.

[14] GIZ, Solar Ice Maker Manufacturing Guideline, April 2026. Sections read (pp. 11–12, 18–22). Sulamu deployment (2022), direct-solar design with auxiliary batteries. ↩

[15] Indotrading listing, PT Indoreka Duta Multisukses, 1 t/day block-ice machine, updated 23 May 2026. Seller’s page: “Rp 233.000.000 / Set … Harga Belum Termasuk Pajak PPN”. An advertised price, excluding VAT and solar power; no independent quotation found. ↩

[16] Mesinesbatu.id, VESTREF MEB 010 1 t block-ice machine, undated. Seller’s page: “Total listrik (estimasi) : 4.475 Watt”. Rated power of a different machine, used only to estimate energy per kg. ↩

[17] RRI Tual, “KDKMP Desa Labetawi Telah Beroperasi Secara Profesional”, 16 July 2026. Read in full. The Labetawi village cooperative operating its KNMP facilities with an investor. ↩

[18] KKP (PDSPKP), “Operasionalisasi Kampung Nelayan Merah Putih”, 8 September 2026. Sections read (pp. 21–25, 32–37). Cooperative management, support teams, Agrinas managerial staffing and written agreements for private partners. ↩

[19] Florespedia, “Nelayan Kesulitan Dapat Es Balok, DKP Sikka Bantah Praktik Borongan dan Calo di Pabrik Es”, 16 November 2026. Read in full. “harga es balok yang dijual langsung di tempat produksi milik pemerintah masih Rp 15.000 per balok”; each unit about 10 t/day. Block weight not given. ↩

Competitors and substitutes

Who What they offer Price In Maluku’s remote landings?
Solar Ice Maker (AIREF with GIZ, IPNLF, ASTB) Donor-built plant Community-run, locally trained operators Not published; a Kawa fisher’s ice costs fell to a third [4] Yes Kawa, West Seram; also Sulamu, NTT [3]
NUSACUBE (PT Alana Green Electric) Solar ice units Two units, up to 900 kg/day Not published [2] Unknown Operates in East Java; Maluku searches found nothing
Kampung Nelayan Merah Putih plants (KKP, village cooperatives) State-funded plants Ice, cold stores, Agrinas managers No current Maluku price; Rp800/kg at Biak in 2023 [6] Yes e.g. Labetawi, Tual [17] [18]
Town block-ice plants (private and government) Fetched ice Buyer travels by boat Rp4,000/kg at the plant (East Java) [2]; about Rp4,500/kg with fuel (Mentawai) [8] Unknown No Maluku price found
Home freezers Homemade ice Fails in power cuts Household electricity and bags [4] Substitute
Grid extension or village solar Power for local ice PLN plans for 10,000+ villages Tariffs [1] Substitute; timing unknown
Selling the catch at once Doing without ice Lower prices [3] Substitute

Economics workings (central case, one plant)

All amounts per plant per year unless stated. Assumed exchange rate Rp 16,500 = US$1. These are illustrations built from the sources and stated assumptions, not a supplier quote.

Step Calculation Status
Freezing machine Rp 233 m, before VAT, 1 t/day Advertised [15]
Other non-solar set-up Rp 250–400 m (site, water, insulated store, shipping, installation, tax, contingency); central Rp 325 m Assumption
Non-solar capital Rp 233 m + Rp 325 m = Rp 558 m (range Rp 483–633 m) Calculation
Capital repayment Rp 558 m × 0.2013 (8 years at 12%) ≈ Rp 112 m Assumption on term and rate
Local wages 2 × Rp 3,334,490 × 13 months ≈ Rp 87 m Wage sourced [12]; staffing assumed
Spares reserve 5% × Rp 558 m ≈ Rp 28 m Assumption
Regional technicians, sales, admin Rp 90 m (range Rp 70–110 m) Assumption
Land, water, insurance, working capital Rp 25 m (range Rp 20–30 m) Assumption
Fixed cost Rp 112 m + 87 m + 28 m + 90 m + 25 m ≈ Rp 342 m Calculation
Power per kg 4.475 kW × 24 h ÷ 1,000 kg = 0.107 kWh/kg × US$ 0.29 × Rp 16,500 ≈ Rp 514/kg (solar capital is inside this cost, not charged twice) Rated power [16]; cost estimate [1]; full-load use assumed
Sales at Kawa’s output 176,000 kg × Rp 2,750 ≈ Rp 484 m Output reported [4]; price assumed
Surplus Rp 484 m − Rp 342 m − (176,000 × Rp 514 ≈ Rp 90 m) ≈ Rp 52 m (range Rp 8–95 m), before tax Calculation
Break-even volume Rp 342 m ÷ (Rp 2,750 − Rp 514) ≈ 153 t (range 133–173 t) Calculation
At 100 t Rp 275 m − Rp 342 m − Rp 51 m ≈ −Rp 118 m Calculation
One collector’s volume 400 kg × 40–52 weeks = 16–21 t Weekly need sourced [8]; weeks assumed
Group-owned plant Rp 342 m − Rp 90 m regional + Rp 30 m outside technician ≈ Rp 282 m fixed; Rp 282 m ÷ (Rp 2,750 − Rp 514) ≈ 126 t Calculation on assumptions

Weakest inputs: the selling price (no Maluku price found), the non-solar set-up cost, and the energy figure, which uses another machine’s nameplate rating and a village-level estimate rather than measured Kawa consumption or a quoted installed solar system. The cash cost of the solar panels is not quoted.

Market size workings

Step Calculation Status
Base 1,074 coastal villages in Maluku Sourced [7]
Possible sites 1,074 × 20–35% × 15–25% × 70–90% ≈ 23–85 Assumed shares
Maluku ceiling 23–85 sites × 176 t × Rp 2,750/kg ≈ Rp 11–41 bn a year Calculation
Year 2 4–6 active plants × Rp 484 m ≈ Rp 1.9–2.9 bn sales; surplus Rp 0.2–0.3 bn after site allocations Illustration
Year 5 12–18 plants in Maluku, North Maluku (946 villages) and NTT (1,019) × Rp 484 m ≈ Rp 5.8–8.7 bn sales; surplus about Rp 0.6–0.9 bn before tax Illustration [7]
Wider context National ice for small-scale capture fisheries, on the research’s method, roughly Rp 2.8–8.9 trillion a year Illustrative context [13]

Routes considered

Cooperative Ice Operations is the main alternative: a firm paid a fee (we assumed Rp 400/kg) to run and repair plants that cooperatives or the state already own, including KNMP plants. Idle and badly run plants are documented [6], and KKP’s guidance allows private partners under written agreements [18], but no budget for an outside operator was found, KKP and Agrinas already provide support, and at 176 t a year the fee earns only about Rp 70 m a plant, less than two local wages and power. The test is whether any cooperative board will sign a priced operating contract.

Folded into Landing Ice Network: written forward orders with a price cap before building; collectors helping run a site, paid for that work; production planned around daily catch calls; regional spare-parts stocks; trained local staff for routine care with regional technicians for repairs; processor finance where a tuna buyer wants better-chilled fish.

  • Floating ice barge. Adds a vessel and weather risk while every landing needs ice at the same peak.
  • Swappable ice modules. Spare machines and sea handling add capital to a plant with thin margins.
  • Credit secured on ice stock. Ice melts or is used, so it cannot secure a loan.
  • Central production with insulated boxes. Weekly deliveries outlast the boxes’ two to three days and bring back the boat trip.
  • Solar units also selling water and cold storage. No sourced off-season buyers for the extra services.
  • Repairs by supply-boat crews. Crews lack refrigeration skills and add liability.
  • Direct regional operating contracts with KKP. KNMP plants are run by cooperatives, and no such contract exists.

Open questions

  • What Maluku collectors pay per kilogram today, and how much they buy across a year: collectors and village fisheries officers could answer.
  • How much of Kawa’s output was sold, at what price, and what maintenance cost: the AIREF, GIZ and IPNLF teams hold these records.
  • The full installed cost of a 1 t/day solar plant on a remote island, with service terms: refrigeration and solar installers.
  • Which landings have funded KNMP or donor plants coming: KKP and provincial fisheries offices.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *