Could a crew paid per parcel end the courier queues at East Jakarta warehouses?

Written by

in

On 11 November, during the “11.11” sales promotion run by online marketplaces, motorbike couriers at a parcel warehouse in Cakung, East Jakarta, waited two to three hours to collect the orders they had been booked to deliver [2]. The warehouse is where online shops’ orders are picked off shelves, packed and handed to riders, many of them ride-hailing motorbike drivers [3]. Around 13:00 the queue boiled over: couriers and staff threw goods at each other until security calmed it [2] [3]. The warehouse’s security officer gave the cause plainly: about 3,000 instant and same-day orders had come in, the goods were still being packed when the riders arrived, and the orders were not handed out in stages, so every rider waited until their name and order number were called [3].

The puzzle is who pays for those lost hours. Not the warehouse: the riders’ waiting cost it nothing. Yet the warehouse already spends heavily on the people who pack and sort, and buys them in a way that rewards nobody for getting parcels out of the door on time. That points to a business: a crew that is paid for each parcel it hands to a courier within an agreed time, rather than for the hours it works.

Three thousand orders and one call

A parcel warehouse of this kind sits between the online shop and the rider. Orders arrive from a marketplace’s system; workers find each item, pack it, label it and put it where the courier will collect it. Carrier sorting hubs work the same way one step later, sorting packed parcels by destination. In both, the warehouse operator (a delivery company, a marketplace or a seller’s dispatch centre) pays for the labour; the couriers are not part of that bill.

On a promotion day the orders arrive faster than the floor can pack them. At Cakung, collection had run since about 09:00 and the queue only cleared around 15:00 [3]. Indonesia’s consumer protection agency, BPKN, a government body that advises on consumer rights, said afterwards that operators must plan sorting, pickup and delivery capacity for promotions and evaluate staff numbers and queue arrangements; no injuries or material losses had been reported [1]. It is a recurring kind of peak: national parcel volumes run between about 7 million parcels a day, by a minister’s 2025 count [12], and 25 to 27 million, by the courier association ASPERINDO’s chair in 2026 [11]; the association says the courier sector employs about 6 million people [10].

One promotion-day order, today and with a crew that owns release

  1. 1. Orders arrive
    About 3,000 instant and same-day orders reached the Cakung warehouse on 11 November
  2. 2. Pick and pack
    Today: still packing when riders arrive. Proposed: instant orders packed first in a priority lane
  3. 3. Stage
    Proposed: packed orders placed by zone as they are finished
  4. 4. Release
    Today: riders wait until their name and number are called. Proposed: zone lead calls riders by time slot
  5. 5. Handover scan
    Proposed: each parcel scanned as the rider takes it; the scan is the billing record
  6. 6. Invoice
    Proposed: parcels released within the agreed window × rate per parcel, monthly
Today the whole wave is called once it is packed; under the proposed crew each zone is handed over as it is ready, and each handover is the invoice line.Based on sources [3] and our own reasoning.

Who is paid when a parcel waits

Warehouse and hub labour is usually bought by the head. The largest listed supplier, PT Personel Alih Daya (PADA, trading as Persada), supplies sorters, couriers and tracers to e-commerce courier operations; it advertised freelance sorter jobs at “Cakung DC” in June 2026 at Rp2.8–6.0 million a month [6] and courier jobs at Shopee Express’s Pulogadung hub nearby [7]. Its courier business earned Rp320.21 billion in 2025 [4], and the group kept a gross margin of just 3.7% in the first half of 2026: Rp916 billion of revenue against Rp882 billion of direct costs [5]. That is the strongest record we found of what these buyers already spend, though it includes delivery couriers as well as warehouse crews. We found no record of what a hub operator pays per parcel for its packing and sorting labour.

A margin that thin suggests the outsourcer passes the wage bill through with a small fee on top; PADA does not publish its billing terms, so this is our inference. The alternative is hiring freelancers directly at the Jakarta minimum wage of Rp5,729,876 a month for 2026 [8], plus the employer’s social-security contributions [9]. Either way the operator buys hours. The mechanism, in one sentence: the operator pays for hours whether or not parcels are ready, the system releases a whole wave of orders at once, and the cost of a late release lands on couriers who are not party to the labour contract. Machines do not remove it. J&T Express says it runs automatic sorting in 19 of its sorting centres [13], and Pos Indonesia uses sorting robots at its East Jakarta processing centre [14], but both automate the sort at large centres; the Cakung delay was in packing and release [3].

A crew billed per parcel out the door

The Released-parcel hub crew would be a company that takes over a warehouse floor’s packing, staging and handover, and invoices only for parcels handed to a courier within an agreed window. Per-unit pricing of warehouse work is already normal on the seller side: one Jakarta fulfilment warehouse, Tiximax, lists picking and packing at Rp12,000 per order, materials included [16]. What is new is applying it to carriers’ hubs and marketplace dispatch centres, and putting the crew in charge of release.

Related Business Opportunity:  Could a Jakarta company sell restaurants frozen chicken by the month, cheaper than fresh?

Walk through one promotion-day shift at a dispatch centre expecting 3,000 orders. The crew arrives before the wave and scans goods in. Instant and same-day orders go to a priority packing lane, since those are the ones riders were queuing for at Cakung [3]. As each order is packed it is staged in a zone, and that zone’s lead calls riders in by time slot instead of waiting for the whole batch. Each parcel is scanned when a rider takes it; that scan is both the handover record and the invoice line. Packers whose phase is finished go home rather than waiting on the clock. At month end the operator pays the number of parcels released within the window times the agreed rate, with a premium for the peak hours. The operator gets a known cost per parcel and fewer queues; riders collect as goods are ready.

Selling it would start small: a priced surge contract for promotion days only, leaving the operator’s normal crew in place, then conversion to the monthly floor once the numbers are visible. The first customers would be second-tier carriers and marketplace or seller dispatch centres in Cakung, Pulogadung and Bekasi that staff with outsourced or freelance crews, rather than the largest automated hubs. PADA already works in that area [6] [7] and is the rival to beat. Staffinc, a national workforce outsourcer that sells placement with measured performance targets [15], may also be present; our searches did not settle whether it staffs parcel hubs there.

The 11 per cent that decides it

Wages cannot be the advantage. Every crew in Jakarta pays at least the same minimum wage and the same contributions, so an hour of floor labour costs every operator roughly the same: about Rp36,000 all-in on our assumptions (minimum wage over 208 hours, plus contributions, supervision and absence cover). The only way to charge less per parcel than the operator’s own hires, and still earn a margin, is to clear more parcels in each paid hour. On our model, a crew that keeps about 6% for itself beats direct hiring only if it is at least about 11% more productive, and beats PADA’s crews only above about 7%. At an assumed 200 parcels per worker-hour for direct hires, that is roughly Rp181 per parcel for the operator’s own crew, about Rp188 through PADA, and a price of about Rp175 from a crew clearing 230 an hour: roughly a seventieth of what Tiximax lists for a packed order [16]. Those rupiah amounts move with the assumed pace, which will be slower where orders are packed rather than only sorted; the 11% threshold does not, because the wage is the same for every crew.

Modelled labour cost per parcel to the warehouse operator

Operator’s own freelance hires≈ Rp181
Through PADA≈ Rp188
Released-parcel hub crew, price≈ Rp175
Released-parcel hub crew, its cost≈ Rp165
Same minimum wage for every crew; the difference comes only from parcels cleared per paid hour (200 for direct hires, 230 assumed for the new crew).Estimate based on sources [5] [8] [9].

Could the crew find that much? Its sources of gain are concrete: staged release keeps riders and packers from idling together, phase-split shifts stop paying packers to wait, and a lead who owns the handover can pace the floor. None of it has been measured. The size of the prize is also modest. If East Jakarta and Bekasi hold 40 to 120 hub or dispatch sites that buy crews this way, a figure we assumed and have not counted, winning three to eight of them would bring Rp11–60 billion of revenue a year and Rp0.4–4.8 billion of gross profit at a 4–8% margin. That supports a dedicated company only at the upper end: at least five sites and margins of 6–8%, twice PADA’s. Beyond it lie the hub clusters of Surabaya, Bandung and Semarang, and brands’ own fulfilment centres on promotion days.

The challenges are real. PADA could offer per-parcel terms on the sites it would otherwise lose, and the advantage lasts only while the crew’s know-how stays ahead. The operator gives up control of its floor, and must want to. Workers paid partly on output may push back on the pace or leave after a hard peak. And the company that owns the ordering system, the carrier or the marketplace, must let a site lead release orders in stages; at Cakung the orders went out as one wave [3]. Each would gain something: the operator a lower, known cost and fewer incidents under public pressure [1], workers steadier work and output pay, the system owner fewer queues. Whether any of them would trade what they give up is unknown.

So could a crew paid per parcel end the courier queues? It could shorten them, because it would own the release that failed at Cakung, but operators will only hire it if it costs them less than their own crew, and that depends on one number. The documented part is the queue, the wave release and an outsourcing market worth hundreds of billions of rupiah a year at a thin margin. The inferred part is that hours-based buying leaves nobody owning release. The unknown and decisive part is whether a crew can clear 11% more parcels per paid hour. One timed shift would answer it: on a promotion day at one partner dispatch centre, split the floor between the new crew and the centre’s own hires and count parcels released per worker-hour. A gain below 11% ends the idea; above it, priced written offers to five operations heads would show whether they sign. Former hub managers, a second-tier carrier willing to lend a site, or a mid-size outsourcer with a worker pool could each settle part of that.

Related Business Opportunity:  Could a specialist chilli supplier win North Maluku's nickel-estate kitchens?

What has to be true

The business described above stands on these claims, listed in the order we would test them.

  1. What hub operators pay per parcel for sorting and packing labour today is close to Rp180–190 per parcel
    Our inference from the sources · Hub / DC operations heads
    Built from UMP, BPJS and PADA’s 3.7% margin at an assumed 200 parcels/worker-hour; no buyer-side price found [5] [8] [9]
    Would break if: Operators report labour cost per parcel well below Rp175
    Cheapest test: Ask three operations heads for their monthly crew bill and parcels processed
  2. Hub and DC operations heads will pay per parcel released within an agreed time instead of buying headcount
    Not yet tested · Hub / DC operations heads
    They already pay outsourcers (PADA courier segment Rp320.21bn) [4]; fulfilment for sellers is already priced per order [16] [4] [16]
    Would break if: Priced written offers at about Rp175 per released parcel are refused by three operations heads
    Cheapest test: Send priced written offers to five East Jakarta–Bekasi hub or DC operations heads and record replies
  3. A crew that owns packing, staging and release clears at least 11% more parcels per worker-hour than the same hub’s own freelance hires
    Not yet tested · The entrant’s crew
    Labour cost is fixed by UMP and BPJS, so productivity is the only route to undercutting; no timed comparison found [8] [9]
    Would break if: A timed peak-day comparison at one hub shows a gain under 11%
    Cheapest test: Run one double-date shift at a partner DC with a split floor: entrant crew vs own hires, count released parcels per worker-hour
  4. The carrier or marketplace system owner lets the crew stage order release instead of releasing the whole wave at once
    Not yet tested · Release-system owner (carrier or marketplace)
    At Cakung the orders were not released in stages [3] [3]
    Would break if: Release logic cannot be delegated or paced at site level
    Cheapest test: Ask two DC operators whether site leads can hold and release orders by slot in their dispatch system
  5. Sorters and packers accept output-linked pay at the pace the crew needs and stay through repeated peaks
    Not yet tested · Frontline sorters and packers
    Freelance sorter pay advertised Rp2.8–6.0m/month [6] [6]
    Would break if: Turnover after the first peak exceeds what training cost allows
    Cheapest test: Recruit one 20-person crew on a base-plus-output offer and track retention over two double dates
  6. Enough non-automated hub and DC sites exist in East Jakarta–Bekasi (40–120 scopes) for 3–8 contracts
    Not yet tested · Hub / DC operations heads
    Would break if: A site count finds fewer than about 25 eligible sites
    Cheapest test: Map carrier hubs and marketplace dispatch DCs in Cakung, Pulogadung and Bekasi from carrier and job-ad listings
  7. PADA does not match per-parcel pricing on contested sites before the entrant holds five sites
    Our inference from the sources · PADA (incumbent)
    PADA’s revenue is tied to hours supplied at a 3.7% margin [5] [5]
    Would break if: PADA offers per-parcel terms to the entrant’s first prospects
    Cheapest test: Ask prospects whether their outsourcer has offered output pricing

Research Notes

The sources, calculations and evidence records behind this investigation. Numbered citations in the article link here; ↩ returns to the text.

Sources

  1. Gudang Ekspedisi Cakung Ricuh, BPKN Minta Konsumen Tak Jadi Korban ↩

    detikFinance, 12 November 2026. Read in full. BPKN’s statement: operators should evaluate warehouse capacity, staff numbers and queue arrangements and plan sorting, pickup and delivery capacity for promotions; no victims or material losses known at publication.

  2. Ricuh 11.11 di Gudang Ekspedisi Cakung, Kurir Lempar-lempar Barang ↩

    detikNews, 11 November 2026. Read in full. “Disebutkan bahwa kurir sampai antre pick-up barang selama 2-3 jam.” The 2–3 hour figure is the narrative accompanying the viral video, as reported.

  3. Viral keributan kurir ojol di gudang ekspedisi Cakung ↩

    Kompas.com, 11 November 2026. Read in full. The site’s security officer: about 3,000 instant and same-day orders; goods still being packed; orders “tidak dibagikan secara bertahap” (not handed out in stages); collection from about 09:00, scuffle about 13:00, queue cleared about 15:00. The operator of the warehouse is not named.

  4. Personel Alih Daya (PADA) membalikkan rugi jadi laba bersih pada 2025 ↩

    Kontan. Read on the page. FY2025 segment revenue: courier Rp320.21 billion (includes delivery couriers as well as hub crews).

  5. Bisnis kurir dorong laba bersih PADA meroket 1.239 persen di semester I 2026 ↩

    KabarBursa, 30 September 2026. Read on the page. H1 2026 revenue Rp916.0 billion, cost of revenue Rp882.0 billion, gross margin 3.7%.

  6. Lowongan Sorter Gudang Ekspedisi Cakung DC, PT Personel Alih Daya Tbk ↩

    KitaLulus job listing, 7 June 2026. Read. Freelance sorter, Jakarta Timur, Rp2,800,000–6,000,000 a month. Whether “Cakung DC” is the site of the 11 November incident is not established.

  7. Lowongan Kurir Motor SPX Pulogadung Hub, PT Personel Alih Daya Tbk ↩

    KitaLulus job listing, 3 June 2026. Read by the commissioned research; shows PADA recruiting for a Pulogadung hub.

  8. Naik 6,17 Persen, UMP DKI Jakarta 2026 Ditetapkan Rp5.729.876 ↩

    Berita Jakarta, 24 December 2025. Read. Jakarta’s 2026 provincial minimum wage, Rp5,729,876 a month.

  9. Berapa Besaran Iuran JHT, JKK, JKM, JP dan JKP? ↩

    BPJS Ketenagakerjaan (the state employment social-security agency). Read. Employer pays 3.7% of wages for old-age savings (JHT) and 0.3% for death benefit (JKM); work-accident cover (JKK) 0.24–1.74% by risk class.

  10. Halalbihalal ASPERINDO 2026: sektor kurir serap 6 juta tenaga kerja ↩

    ASPERINDO (the Indonesian courier companies’ association), 10 April 2026. Read by the commissioned research. Courier sector employment about 6 million.

  11. Ketum ASPERINDO: DEAL 2026 jangan berhenti pada deklarasi ↩

    SAPX blog, 23 June 2026. Read. ASPERINDO’s chair: national volume about 25–27 million shipments a day.

  12. PM Komdigi 8/2025 resmi ↩

    Liputan6, 17 May 2025. Read. The communications minister cites seven million parcels sent each day. The gap with [11] is unexplained; we carry both as the range.

  13. Volume pengiriman J&T Express melonjak 65% di semester I 2026 ↩

    Industry.co.id, 27 August 2026. Read by the commissioned research. J&T’s automatic sorting system in 19 sorting centres (company claims).

  14. Robot pekerja sudah muncul di Indonesia ↩

    CNBC Indonesia, 17 March 2026. Read by the commissioned research. Pos Indonesia’s autonomous sorting robots at its East Jakarta processing centre.

  15. Staffinc hadirkan solusi tenaga berbasis teknologi ↩

    Kontan, 27 October 2026. Read by the commissioned research. Staffinc’s placement, training and measured performance targets for frontline work.

  16. Indonesia Fulfillment Pricing ↩

    Tiximax price page, read November 2026. Seller’s list price: pick and pack 12,000 IDR per order, including packing materials. An advertised price, not a transaction record.

Related Business Opportunity:  Could local soybean deliveries cut costs for Central Java’s tofu makers?

Competitors and alternatives

Alternative What it offers Price In East Jakarta–Bekasi hubs?
PADA (Persada) Outsourced sorters, couriers and tracers for e-commerce courier operations Not published; 3.7% group gross margin [5]; sorter pay advertised Rp2.8–6.0 million a month [6] Yes: Cakung DC and Pulogadung hub adverts [6] [7]
Staffinc Workforce outsourcing with placement, training and performance targets [15] Not published Unknown: four targeted searches found no sorter adverts there
Operator’s own freelance hires Direct daily or freelance workers under the operator’s own leads Minimum wage Rp5,729,876 a month [8] plus contributions [9] Everywhere
Automated sorting (J&T, Pos Indonesia) Machines at large sorting centres [13] [14] Capital cost, not published Their own networks; Pos at East Jakarta
Seller fulfilment warehouses (Tiximax) Storage, pick and pack for online sellers [16] Lists Rp12,000 per order Jakarta; serves sellers, not carriers’ hubs
Doing nothing Couriers wait for the wave Couriers’ unpaid time: 2–3 hours on 11 November [2] Peak days

Evidence ledger

  • Observed: the 2–3 hour wait [2]; about 3,000 instant and same-day orders, still being packed, not released in stages [3]; PADA’s courier revenue and 3.7% margin [4] [5]; PADA’s recruiting in the area [6] [7].
  • Inferred: that hub labour is billed by hours supplied (from PADA’s margin; terms unpublished); that nobody on the floor is paid for on-time release.
  • Unknown: who operated the Cakung warehouse and who staffed it; what operators pay per parcel; whether a crew owning release is measurably faster.

Economics workings

Unit: one parcel released to a courier. All figures are our model; only the wage and the JHT and JKM rates are sourced.

Step Calculation Status
Wage per paid hour Rp5,729,876 ÷ 208 h = Rp27,547 Wage sourced [8]; 208 h a month assumed
Load on wage JHT 3.7% + JKM 0.3% = 4.0%; other statutory items (JKK, pension, health, holiday bonus) 15.2%; supervision 7.5%; recruitment and absence 5% → total 31.7% 4.0% sourced [9]; the rest assumed
All-in cost per paid hour Rp27,547 × 1.317 ≈ Rp36,280 Model
Operator’s own hires Rp36,280 ÷ 200 parcels/h ≈ Rp181 per parcel 200 parcels/h assumed
Through PADA Rp181 ÷ (1 − 0.037) ≈ Rp188 per parcel Margin sourced [5]; pass-through billing inferred
Entrant cost Rp36,280 ÷ 230 parcels/h + Rp7 overhead ≈ Rp165 per parcel 230 parcels/h (+15%) and overhead assumed
Entrant price Rp165 × 1.06 ≈ Rp175 per parcel 6% margin assumed
Breakeven against own hires Rp181 ÷ 1.06 ≈ Rp171 cost; (Rp171 − Rp7) = Rp164 → Rp36,280 ÷ Rp164 ≈ 221 parcels/h, +11% over 200 Model
Breakeven against PADA Rp188 ÷ 1.06 ≈ Rp177 cost → ≈ 213 parcels/h, about +7% Model

The weakest input is productivity. The rupiah per parcel scales with the assumed base pace (a packing floor clearing 50 orders an hour would cost about four times as much per order), but the percentage edge needed is set by the margin and overhead, not by the pace.

First market, top down: national 2.6–9.9 billion parcels a year (7–27 million a day × 365 [11] [12]) × East Jakarta–Bekasi share 25% × non-automated, outsourced share 30% × hub labour Rp200–500 per parcel ≈ Rp38–370 billion a year (all three shares assumed).

First market, bottom up: 40–120 hub or dispatch sites (8–12 operators × 4–10 sites, assumed) × 12 monthly invoices × Rp0.30–0.62 billion per site-month (40–80 crew × about Rp7.2–7.8 million billed per worker, assumed) ≈ Rp144–893 billion a year. The bottom-up figure runs two to four times the top-down one because crew contracts cover loading, scanning and administration as well as sorting; we lean on the lower half.

Capturable: 3–8 sites × 12 × Rp0.30–0.62 billion ≈ Rp11–60 billion revenue a year; at a 4–8% margin, Rp0.4–4.8 billion gross profit. Market sizing for the five-year view kept by the research: Rp15–75 billion a year of attainable revenue, taken from PADA’s mid-size accounts and operators’ direct hires rather than its anchor client.

Who has to go along

  • Operations head of the hub or dispatch centre: gains a lower, fixed cost per parcel and fewer incidents (price, speed, quality); gives up control of staging and release. Net unknown.
  • Sorters and packers: could gain output pay and steadier work across peaks (price, access); face pace pressure, with the wage floor unchanged [8]. Net unknown.
  • Owner of the ordering system (carrier or marketplace): gains fewer queue incidents under public pressure [1] (quality); must allow release by stages, which it controls today [3]. Net unknown.
  • PADA loses accounts it would otherwise hold; its likely response is per-parcel terms on contested sites.

Routes considered

Folded into the Released-parcel hub crew: scanning goods in before the wave and packing instant orders first; a priority lane for instant and same-day orders; scanner-led call-ins that size the crew to packing output; time-slot pickup windows opened as packing completes; zone-by-zone release under trained zone leads; scan-to-release counting that doubles as the invoice; shifts split by phase so workers leave when their phase ends; a promotion-day surge contract as the entry route; and a premium rate for the peak window.

  • A shared release scheduler across operators: competing operators peak on the same promotion dates and none has a reason to delay its own release.
  • Truck-mounted sorting lines: they add capital cost where the documented delay was in packing and release, which machines do not stage.
  • One crew rotating across nearby centres: the peaks fall on the same dates and hours, so the crew cannot be in two places when it is needed.
  • Removing floor leads to save cost: it removes the person who owns release, the thing the business sells, for a saving of about Rp9 per parcel.

Open questions

  • What do hub operators pay per parcel for packing and sorting today? Operations heads and outsourcers’ account managers could answer.
  • How many non-automated hub and dispatch sites in Cakung, Pulogadung and Bekasi buy crews this way? Carrier site lists and job adverts would give a count.
  • Can site leads hold and release orders by slot in the marketplace’s or carrier’s dispatch system? Dispatch-centre managers would know.
  • Does Staffinc already staff parcel hubs in East Jakarta?

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *